What’s An Assignment of Claims?
An assignment of claims directs the government to pay a lender instead of the contractor on a contract the lender finances. Tony Gray and Michael Bagley walk through the five steps, the statute and FAR subpart behind it, why it is not automatic, and how sureties and existing lenders fit in, then answer the questions contractors ask most.
What is an assignment of claims?
Michael Bagley: It is a mechanism the government designed for perfecting control of payments when a contractor needs to finance a contract before the government pays. Government contracting differs from the industry standard for regular commercial accounts, so the government had to design a way for contractors, who from a banking standpoint are commercial companies, to finance those contracts.
How does an assignment of claims work, step by step?
Tony Gray: There are five steps. One, the government awards you a contract. Two, you need financing: on a $5 million contract you may have to hire a bunch of employees, with perhaps a 30-day transition period, and you will be meeting payroll while you wait for the government to pay you. So you approach a lender, and the lender agrees to provide working capital.
Three, this is where the assignment of claims comes in. You assign the payment rights by signing an assignment of claims, which is provided to the government. The government is instructed to send the payments it would have made to you to your lender instead. Four, the government makes those payments, paying the invoices and sending the money to the lender you identified. Five, the lender applies the payments to the outstanding balance on the credit facility, and the remaining funds go to your company.
What law authorizes an assignment of claims?
Tony Gray: The current law is 31 U.S.C. § 3727. It traces back to a 1940 law, written when a world war was going on and the government needed contractors to be able to get credit, for example to open a manufacturing plant to produce bullets or shells. That law permitted a qualifying assignment of money due from a government contract to be paid to a financing institution.
In May of 1951 Congress amended the rules governing the assignments and modified some of the provisions on contract payments. In September of 1982 the current code structure was implemented, which was essentially the codification and reorganization of the two earlier laws.
What does FAR 32.8 require?
Tony Gray: FAR Subpart 32.8 is the part of the Federal Acquisition Regulation that addresses assignment of claims. A contractor may assign moneys due under a contract if the contract specifies payments aggregating $1,000 or more, the assignment is made to a bank, trust company or other financing institution, and the contract does not prohibit the assignment. A contract can contain a term that prohibits assignment, so read yours closely to confirm it is feasible. Usually it is not prohibited.
Unless the contract expressly permits otherwise, the assignment covers all unpaid amounts payable under the contract, is made only to one party, and is not subject to further assignment. You cannot assign the claim and have the lender pass it on to a third party later. Finally, the assignee sends a written notice of assignment, together with a true copy of the assignment instrument, to the contracting officer or the agency head. For contracting officers receiving one, FAR 32.8 includes the template for what the notice should look like and how to process it.
Is an assignment of claims automatic?
Michael Bagley: No. The government is not aware that you need one when it awards you the contract, so you have to bring it to the government’s attention through the assignment of claims process. Even once the instrument is created and given to the financing institution, sending the notice with a copy of the instrument can take time. The contracting officer receives it, and it is often turned over to someone internally who handles legal and compliance matters. That is a matter of following procedure, not a lack of knowledge, but it adds more time. Automatic is a far cry from what really happens.
Tony Gray: That is important for contractors to know. There is a time element, so do not expect to send it to the contracting officer and have it implemented automatically.
How does a surety bond affect an assignment of claims?
Michael Bagley: The surety has lien rights. They are technically a lender of sorts, through insurance, so they are essentially first. In any finance relationship someone has to be first on the proceeds, whether that is your bank, a new finance company, or a lender like us, either on all of your accounts or on a particular contract. If an assignment of claims is going to be done on a contract because cash flow is required to perform it, the surety will want to know about it, and in essence has to bless it too. That process can hold up the timing.
Most lenders, even in the government space, look for bonded work and walk away from it, primarily because you are automatically in second position without doing anything. The assignment of claims is a tool that, used properly, lets the lender work with the surety and provide extra cash flow while the bonding company keeps its rights.
Why would I need a second lender, and what happens to my existing lender’s lien?
Michael Bagley: It works the same way as the bonding company, because someone has to be first on the payment. If an existing lender has a lien that encumbers the accounts, which typically covers all assets because that is what most banking institutions do, the collateral belongs to that first institution. The reason a contractor talks to a second institution is typically capacity. The product at the first institution is capped, or it is a loan, and with a loan you cannot go back to the well. With a line you can possibly ask for an increase.
What happens most often is that underwriting at the traditional lender is more complex and more conservative, because they do not have the controls an assignment of claims provides. They can use one but typically do not. A bank will look at your financials, look backwards, and say you are at your max. So you tell them a third party lender will do the assignment of claims on the new contracts. The growth is essentially extra collateral, extra liquidity, and you are asking the first lender for permission to finance it with someone else.
Tony Gray: Matthew and I discussed this in the previous episode, on SBA 7(a) loans. If you have an existing SBA 7(a) loan and bring in a private lender for a line of credit, you implement an intercreditor agreement.
What does an intercreditor agreement do?
Michael Bagley: It is an agreement between creditors, and technically a tri-party agreement, because the borrower has to sign it too. The other creditor says: I am aware you are in first on your collateral, and I am going to take this pile of accounts and put them in first on my side. The first institution is then in second on what the new lender takes, and the reverse. The agreement states expressly what is being carved out.
Say a customer has a new Department of Veterans Affairs award for $10 million a year, a base year plus four. As a banker you look at the company’s financial history and say it looks like they need another million dollar line, but you cannot do it. My advice is to go ask the lender first. Often the existing lender can increase your line and cover your cash flow. But it does not work with something like an SBA loan, which cannot go through a fast process. If the lender will agree to a simple two or three page document, we can carve out those contracts and put an assignment of claims in place on them, so the government pays us only on those.
That is the difference between all assets and one contract. The assignment of claims is the mechanism that lets us pick one off. Anything it is not on gets paid to the contractor’s account, and anything it is on goes to the financing company’s account, because the SAM record drives the bank. With a traditional line, all the money goes into your checking account as usual, you account for it, and you provide reports such as an AR report. With an assignment of claims we pull that one payment out of the mix and the government pays us directly. You win the award, we get it set up, and you can cash flow the onboarding, the mobilization and the payroll.
Tony Gray: Think of baseball. The first lender is on first base, maybe with an SBA 7(a) loan collateralized by the equipment you bought. The new lender tells them it is on second base, and that any ball that comes its way relating to the specific contract it is helping you fund is the money it gets if things go sideways. That way everyone on the team knows who has access to what.
What goes wrong when I wait until the last minute?
Tony Gray: It is the same drum we have been beating since episode one: do not wait until after you have won the contract to find funding. For an assignment of claims you are moving paperwork through your lender, any other lender involved, and the government, while you are trying to meet payroll, buy equipment and execute on the contract. Do not assume it will move quickly. Reach out to your lenders when you think you might get the award, or even while you are bidding, so you understand what you need to position in advance.
What if my contract prohibits assignment?
Michael Bagley: You cannot ignore it. If the contract has a clause stating it cannot be assigned, that is a hard stop. A contractor with a multitude of contracts may not be reading every clause, but when that clause appears, it applies.
There are other mechanisms for controlling the funds that sit outside the assignment of claims and use the commercial rules, and there are experts who know how to use them. Consider a bank giving you a million dollar line, which you tap regularly, when all your collateral is federal government and every contract has a prohibition on assignment. They are not ignoring the prohibition, because they did not file an assignment of claims, but their loan agreement has a different mechanism for getting repaid.
The process is not inherently slow. It was written in 1940, when everything was carbon copies. You can follow the FAR to the letter with ink-based paper signatures and wait, or you can work with a team that knows the contacts, the payment office people and the agencies, and knows what they are supposed to be looking for. Sometimes the officer does not recognize what to do with it, and we can coach them along. If money is needed and an assignment of claims cannot be done fast enough or is prohibited, a partner who understands the industry and the commercial banking rules has other tools.
Does an assignment of claims mean I lose control of my contract?
Michael Bagley: No, not by any means. You see language in federal and commercial contracts, construction for example, that says the contract cannot be assigned, and that refers to the work. You were awarded the contract because you are registered in SAM, have the right NAICS codes and your performance shows what you can do. You are not assigning the work or the contract. You are only assigning the payment. An assignment of payment is protected through the assignment of claims and the FAR, and on the commercial side by UCC Article 9. It is the same general concept in the finance world.
Tony Gray: Contractors sometimes worry about how the contracting officer will perceive it, and whether it will upset them. It will not. It is in legislation. It is a law, and there is a FAR part that specifically addresses it.
For contracting officers: when you create your acquisition strategy and solicitation, consider whether your awardee may need a line of credit. More and more contracting officers are recognizing that financing is necessary for successful contract execution. If you reuse a template from an earlier contract, check that the assignment of claims is authorized in the solicitation documents before you release them.
Does an assignment of claims apply to subcontractors?
Michael Bagley: No. In the industry, subcontractors working for a prime all consider themselves government contractors, but technically a subcontractor sits under a commercial contract. It may have flow downs of the clauses, but that does not make the subcontractor privy to the federal law that assigns the moneys. It falls under UCC commercial law.
Can I keep my bank?
Michael Bagley: Yes, and we encourage you to keep your operating account and your regular bank account. We may be assigning one contract out of five, or two or ten, or all of them, but your other deposits and your regular operations continue as usual. Some of our customers prefer to switch banks, but it is not a priority.
Does an assignment of claims apply to state and local contracts?
Michael Bagley: No. It has nothing to do with the FAR or the Assignment of Claims Act. The only exception is the District of Columbia, which follows the FAR the same way. I learned that over 25 years ago, sent in an assignment of claims according to their rules, and it worked.
Many set-aside contractors start out in state and local work and then register with the federal government, so we have to discover from each municipality how it expects to be notified. We lean toward the commercial process and what is in the contract. If the contract does not define it, we assume the commercial process covers it, and every state is under the UCC. If a municipality pushes back and says to do it a different way, we learn. Generally we have not had challenges with other municipalities.
Read more on this
This is an edited version of the conversation: spoken repetition is removed and each answer leads with its point. Every figure and example is as said in the episode. For financing specific to your business, talk to us.
Ready to fund your contract?
No obligation, talk to a govcon financing specialist, not a call center. We'll structure capital around your award.