Price to Win with Lenders
Tony Gray talks with Rich Wagner, founder of the government contracting consultancy Richard Wagner and Company, about bringing a lender into pricing and capture before an award rather than after it. They cover why thin margins and the cost of capital belong in the price, what to tell a lender and when, and how a transition period and net 30 payment terms stretch the time before the first payment.
How did Rich Wagner get into government contracting?
Rich Wagner: In a non-traditional way. Out of graduate school, in the late 1990s and early 2000s, I joined a private equity firm. My job was consolidation: I flew around the country meeting management teams that owned government contractors, mostly services firms in security, logistics and custodial work, to buy them into a roll-up. After 9/11 the security side grew enormously. Meeting those teams was an ongoing masterclass. The firms that won work had a lot in common, and so did the firms that did not.
After two or three years a government contractor hired me to run an internal M&A program, which meant more travel and more management meetings, and the business development group would debrief me on what I had learned. Over six or seven years I built a Rolodex of business owners in GovCon, which is great for teaming, and a sense of what worked. When I moved into bidding I still had to learn bid, proposal and capture, but I already understood how price, technical and past performance fit together. That company was acquired in 2009. I had equity as part of the management team, and after the transaction I started my own firm.
We have since grown to about 20 people, working in 16 countries, with hundreds of clients and 400 or 500 client engagements a year. There is a process-driven approach behind our win rate, which could be another podcast.
Why bring a lender into price to win before the award?
Rich Wagner: Most people leave it until after the award. There are two reasons to do it at the very start. First, public sector work, especially labor-intensive services, is competitively bid, so margins are compressed and the pressure on them is downward. Second, capital has a cost. If you do not account for that cost inside a tight margin, you set yourself up for a problem after the award. Win it first and figure it out later sounds fine, but you cannot undo math, and math is undefeated.
When the math works against you after the fact, you end up cutting corners and doing things that hurt performance or run afoul of the rules. Bringing the lender in at the beginning lets it work with you before the problem becomes existential, and leaves you free to move other levers in your price to stay competitive. It decides whether the award notice is something you celebrate for a week or for five minutes.
Tony Gray: We call it the “uh-oh, we won” scenario. A contractor wins, then realizes it needs working capital to hire and onboard staff and to buy equipment, finds it does not have the cash, and has to scramble to find a lender in days or weeks. Those conversations need to happen much earlier.
How do you bring a lender in when your pricing is proprietary?
Rich Wagner: Treat the lender as a trusted partner, because its interest is aligned with yours: it wants you to win. It already has financial visibility into your firm through the relationship. Be fully honest and transparent, because that avoids the problems a lack of transparency creates later.
My clients typically tell their lender as soon as they identify something they want to bid, about six months out: the size, scope and complexity of the work, where it is, and any concerns about absorbing it. Most contractors bid more than one thing, and some of our clients win more than one award in a week, sometimes awards they did not anticipate. Without an ongoing conversation you stack lending issues on top of each other: three startups in six weeks and no working capital for the next four months. That is how organizations win contracts and then fail the next year. Not for lack of revenue, but because they could not survive the initial award phase.
Some of our clients hold a monthly check-in call with their lender. It is a chance to see whether their volume of business justifies an adjustment to their rates or their lines, and it keeps the lender aware of the work they are doing, the work they expect to win and what is on their radar. If the business fails, that is a bad day for the lender too. Fifteen minutes a month puts you in a very different working capital position.
Tony Gray: Bringing the lender in early keeps you from becoming a victim of your own success, because you understand your working capital capacity months before the contracts you hope to win.
Should business developers be part of the lender conversation?
Tony Gray: Business developers are often cut out of finance discussions. If you lead the company, include them. Then the team understands that it cannot go after everything, because winning certain awards in a certain sequence could create a working capital problem.
Depending on the lender, it may also have relationships across the industry. If you are bidding at a particular agency, it may introduce you to clients who would make good teammates, share what it knows about the market, or point you to subject matter experts who could advise on the opportunity.
Increasingly, the government requires a financial feasibility letter in the solicitation, which is an early signal to bring your lender in. Financial capacity is also a competitive advantage. If a competitor has just won a major contract and faces its own working capital strain, or the work is complex enough to stretch bidders’ resources, a business developer can make the case to the customer that it should look for bidders with the financial resources to execute successfully.
Should the lender be involved while you build the cost model?
Rich Wagner: Yes. My bias is that a lender should be involved at every step. It needs to know your strategy and how competitive your price is, because it grows only if you grow. Treat it as a route to a healthy transition rather than as an adversary or a cost, so that you perform without labor stress caused by capital problems and earn the best possible performance reference.
The lender will also know a lot about transition periods, startup costs and invoice cycles, because it probably has clients in the same sector working with the same agencies. Here is something many contractors do not think about. Government payment terms are net 30. If you have a 90-day transition, you do not invoice for the first month of work until that month ends, and you are paid 30 days after that, another 60 days after the start date. You are 150 days into spending money on the contract. The lender should know that, and help you plan how to cover those four to five months and how long it will take to earn enough to offset the cost of capital.
Focus on the base period. By the option periods the work is up and running and the transition costs are sunk. So bring the lender in early, keep it in the process, and talk honestly about the payment and invoice cycle, the number of FTEs, what the transition requires, and startup costs such as travel and equipment. Many of the firms we work with are security companies that have to buy uniforms and run a lot of training. These are all capture questions, along with location, payment terms and how big and financially independent your competitors are, before you even reach workers’ compensation rates and general liability insurance. They decide the stretch from award to performance, and that is where the lender adds the most value.
What happens when your lender learns about a new award late?
Tony Gray: The worst way for a lender to learn about an “uh-oh, we won” is 90 days after award and transition, because you broke your covenants. That does not inspire trust or show bankable behavior.
Brought in early, a lender can give you an advantage on price. It may be willing to work with you on the cost of capital knowing you may win another contract at the same time. In episode 15, Michael Bagley made the same point: a good lender rolls up its sleeves, sees your growth and offers you products that may be better priced, which lets you compete harder on price. You may never know that unless you include the lender early.
Early involvement also gives a good lender the chance to say a deal is too much risk for it. A bank might say it cannot provide the product but introduce a private lender who can, so the right lending partners are in place before you need them. Ask for something fast after you have won, and lenders often cannot move that quickly, which leaves you at the mercy of the market.
Why do government contractors fail after winning?
Rich Wagner: When contractors fail, this is the primary reason. Not because they cannot do the work or cannot hire, but because they do not have the working capital to run the contract effectively, efficiently and correctly. It sounds like a winner’s problem, and it is, but it is also existential. Without the capacity to perform, either you fail at the start, or the next five years of performance are miserable, you build bad past performance, and that chills your ability to win more work. Solving it early is tedious planning, and it is probably the most important thing you can do.
Read more on this
This is an edited version of the conversation: spoken repetition is removed and each answer leads with its point. Every figure and example is as said in the episode. For financing specific to your business, talk to us.
Ready to fund your contract?
No obligation, talk to a govcon financing specialist, not a call center. We'll structure capital around your award.