How To Pick The Right Lender?
Tony Gray, Matthew Gillman and Michael Bagley cover how to choose a lender for a government contracting business when the interest rate is only part of the decision. They discuss why a lender should know the industry and look at where the business is going, how to be a good client from onboarding onward, who services the account, and how a lending relationship grows with the company.
How do you pick a great lender?
Matthew Gillman: Start with someone who knows what you do and knows your industry well. We do the same from our side: in industries we do not know well, we generally do not look for customers, because we could not give them good service. It may seem like it is just money, but every industry has different challenges, processes and things it needs to succeed. Across government contractors we see different agencies, systems, billing challenges and contract types. Go to a lender that does not understand that and you get a lot of questions, a lot of uncertainty, and someone who is not confident in the decision to provide capital. So work with somebody you know understands your business, and challenge them. Ask questions, and make sure you are getting what you are being told.
Tony Gray: It cuts both ways. A lender that does not understand your industry may decide it is too risky, and you spend weeks engaging with it only to learn it will not fund you. Or it may be too liberal in its underwriting and give you a product it should not have, because it was not the right product for your business, your stage of growth and your risk profile.
Why does a lender need to understand where your business is going?
Michael Bagley: Any lender can underwrite any company, but a generalist focuses strictly on financials. Financials tell a huge story, but in government contracting they look backwards: they show where you came from, and where you came from often does not support where you are going, especially in fast growth. It is fine for a lender to look at you from a financial standpoint too, because then it can give you some guidance. What you want is a lender with the tools, the team and the intelligence to understand where your business is, and more importantly where it is going.
That is rare. Most finance companies focus strictly on the past. Take a company that did five million in revenue last year with contracts that will take it to 15 million. Most lenders will give it no credit for that rise, because they do not know how it will perform. A lender that knows the industry looks at the pipeline and the award structure, the number of people and the mobilization costs, and can understand how to give credit for it.
What is the difference between a consultative lender and a consultant?
Tony Gray: You also want people on the lender’s team, in underwriting and business development, who understand the operations of your industry. And you want a lender that is consultative rather than consulting. Regulation prevents traditional lenders such as banks from providing consulting services. Consultative means a lending partner that understands your business and wants to provide value even while you are a prospect, even if you never become a client because you do not fit its underwriting standards.
As a borrower, use those resources. A lender has sharp financial people looking at your numbers, so ask them whether they see an issue with your financials, and what you could do to mitigate the risks they see ahead. That goes well beyond the interest rate, and you should be planning a long-term relationship with that lender.
How do you become a good client from onboarding onward?
Michael Bagley: It comes down to transparency. A lender asks questions for a reason. Being cagey, holding data back or deciding something is not relevant harms the relationship, and during underwriting it can keep you from getting the right product. By onboarding most of that is vetted, and the two sides should agree how they will communicate, including through the handoff from the credit team to the portfolio team.
It depends on the product. With a straightforward loan, once the money is in your account there is little onboarding. But where a lender funds payroll against an award, you are touching each other at many points, sometimes two or three times a month. Many of our clients are in fast growth, and we talk with them person to person four or five times a month, as well as the data they see in a portal.
It is the lender’s money, so both sides need an open relationship, and as a client you are trying to keep the lender’s confidence in the risk high. When the lender asks for updated financials, share them. If they are not available, say so. Black and white answers help. If the lender sees that your data is not good and suggests an outside accountant, take the advice, and if cost is a problem, raise it. Good data helps you grow your business.
Who will you work with after you sign with a lender?
Tony Gray: While you are a prospect you usually talk to a business developer or relationship manager, often with a VP title. Ask whether that person will be your account manager once you are a client, and who else will be involved. Other people join from underwriting and especially at onboarding. Understand who all those players are, who does what and when to reach out to each, so both teams know each other. That is transparency in the relationships, not just in the documents.
What mindset should a borrower bring to a lending relationship?
Matthew Gillman: A lot of it is mindset, and the mindset has to be that we are all on the same team. Sometimes a borrower thinks the lender is always looking for something wrong, and sometimes a lender thinks the borrower is doing something wrong. That is the wrong mindset. Make sure you are comfortable with who you are working with, so that you can go in believing you are in it together. Our goal is for our customers to grow and succeed, and when they do, our business grows too. The common denominator among our best clients is that they believe we are on the same team.
What makes a lending relationship high trust?
Tony Gray: Think of trust as purpose, empathy and truth. Purpose: does the lender understand your industry, what you are trying to accomplish and the right product for you? Truth: are you transparent and accurate in the information you share, with clean documents of the kind we covered in episode 14? Empathy runs both ways. Does your lender understand your situation and the challenges in your business, and are you empathetic toward your lender? Do you see it as a teammate that will help guide you to growth, or as an adversary that will cut you loose if you break a covenant? That applies to any business relationship, and a lending relationship should be no different.
How do you build a long-term relationship with a lender?
Michael Bagley: It depends on the product. With a term loan you make your payments until it is paid off, though your point of contact may still have suggestions for other areas of your business. With a collateralized line of credit you may just draw funds through a system. Then there are products where the lender works with you on the contract, sees your invoices and talks through the data, which is a far closer relationship. In all of them you have to be transparent and willing to take advice as it comes.
From the lender’s side, the way to build a long relationship is to follow the company’s maturation. A small company might come in with one contract and two million a year in revenue. If nobody talks to the owners beyond that contract, the lender does not know what they are bidding on, they are not asking it for advice or for financial support letters to win those bids, and it may not know they have other contracts it could fund. A lender that reviews the financials and talks to the principals regularly has a pulse on what they are trying to achieve.
It also tells the lender when a client has matured. The question I ask is: if this company came to us today as a new prospect, what deal would it get? I do not want clients telling me they found a better deal elsewhere, or feeling awkward asking for a rate cut. A lender can go to them proactively and say they have grown into a different product or a different pricing structure. That creates longevity, and when a client does leave because it has outgrown the lender, it should be a congratulatory moment.
Tony Gray: Look for a lender that can scale with you and offer better products as your risk profile changes, whether that is a lower rate or better terms. While you are shopping, ask lenders for the stories of clients who have scaled and graduated.
What should you do when a lending relationship gets stressful?
Matthew Gillman: Remember that everybody is human. Business gets stressful and things move quickly, and sometimes everyone needs to step back and realize we are doing this together. There is someone on the other end of the phone who is working to help you reach your goal. Sometimes that means taking a breath, slowing down and working out the solution. A borrower has boxes it wants to check and a lender has boxes it needs to check. There is a process on both sides, and the aim is a way for everybody to accomplish what they need.
What if your lender does not offer the product you need?
Matthew Gillman: Lenders and banks rarely do everything well or offer every product. Each tends to offer what it understands and is good at, which does not mean nobody else does the rest. SBA 7(a) loans, which we covered in an earlier episode, are an example of a product we do not offer, made well by other banks and non-banks. A good lender makes introductions to help its customers, and the same applies to other services, such as a payroll provider. You can choose a generalist or one experienced in government contracting. A generalist is not a bad thing, but expect a different kind of relationship.
Who answers the phone when you need your lender?
Matthew Gillman: When things are running hot, you can end up on a carousel: one person does not answer, you call the next, then the next, four calls in two minutes trying to reach someone. What matters is that someone who understands your account always answers. Ask a lender who you will speak to every day, and who you speak to if that person is on vacation. A single point of contact with a backup, and a backup behind that, is what to look for.
What separates a good lender from a great one?
Tony Gray: Think of three tiers. At the base is a general lender with a good product and a reputation for good customer experience, which anybody should expect from any product they buy. Better is a lender that understands your industry: the agencies, how contracts work, what contracting officers do. You can assess that quickly in your first conversations.
To go from better to great, ask who on the team has been in your shoes. Not only bankers or private lenders with long careers in government contracting finance, but people who have been government contractors: up at midnight writing a proposal, working through a financial issue with a contracting officer, running a contract transition or going into a recompete. Ask who has relationships with agency officials, with other contractors who could become teaming partners, and with the industry’s experts, from business development software to accountants and attorneys who understand the industry. A lender with those resources that consistently delivers value in the relationship is the top tier.
Read more on this
- Contract line of credit or payroll funding
- When you outgrow your line of credit
- Contract line of credit
This is an edited version of the conversation: spoken repetition is removed and each answer leads with its point. Every figure and example is as said in the episode. For financing specific to your business, talk to us.
Ready to fund your contract?
No obligation, talk to a govcon financing specialist, not a call center. We'll structure capital around your award.